Albany surgeon wary of Phoebe/Palmyra buyout

John Bagnato

More fallout from Phoebe Putney's acquisition of Palmyra Medical Center . .

An Albany physician that has worked for both hospitals is speaking out on what the acquisition means for Southwest Georgia â" and the picture he paints is not a pretty one.

"It's not a good thing if you have only one source of gasoline," said Dr. John Bagnato of Palmyra Surgical. "It's not a good thing if you have only one source of groceries. And the same applies to healthcare."

Bagnato has practiced healthcare in Southwest Georgia for over a decade.

He doesn't mince words when it comes to what he sees as Phoebe's goal to corner the market on Southwest Georgia Healthcare.

"Anytime they go to buy something, they're overpaying for it," said Bagnato. "There's gotta be a reason for it. One big bonus they get is no more competition."

Bagnato warns that once Palmyra Medical officially becomes Phoebe North, healthcare prices will rise and the quality of services will diminish.

He also admits having a tumultuous past with Phoebe Hospital.

"I've been critical of their business practices both as it relates to pricing, to hoarding money and wealth as well as treatment of the uninsured," said Bagnato. "It's a not-for-profit that doesn't operate as a non-profit at all."

Differences with Phoebe administrators prompted Bagnato and a colleague to begin distributing what became known as the Phoebe Factoids in 2003 â" faxes sent anonymously to other hospitals, doctors, and media outlets detailing the organization's financial holdings, tax returns, and billing practices.

The controversy culminated in criminal charges against Bagnato â" which were later dismissed.

Bagnato says he's also concerned about what effect a healthcare monopoly could have on private practitioners. If any one organization is in a position to dictate where and how physicians can do business, local health care professionals may consider closing their doors.

"I don't know what I'm gonna do yet but I doubt that Phoebe will allow me to continue practicing at Palmyra," said Bagnato.

close video ad
Unmutetoggle ad audio on off